As the story continues, the dark villain Nightmare appears just after Cara Lenard (Darla Crane) has transformed into SuperDarla. He mistakenly believes the masked champion of justice has freed the reporter, and he ultimately overpowers her. SuperDarla quickly finds herself bitgagged and bound to a post with seemingly unbreakable ropes. The booted super-babe struggles against her bindings, but she's apparently in a weakened state and can't free herself. Before long, her sinister host reappears, and he bares SuperDarla's huge breasts. Left alone again, the brave defender of goodness continues to squirm and fight the ropes. Her superhuman strength finally returns, and she breaks the ropes. But Nightmare returns just in time to stop her from escaping. He makes an ominous threat, and SuperDarla has no choice but to surrender to her evil nemesis.